previous |
start |
next
Maths and Gender
What is happening in UK to deal with gender issues through
mathematics teaching
By Irene Duff at
Jyväskylä Euromaths Course in September
2002
The issues
- Attitudes - boys perceive maths as easy, girls perceive
difficulty
- Girls have lower expectations
- Boys are connected thinkers and respond better to traditional
teaching methods
- Girls are more attentive and willing to learn
- Boys can memorise abstract facts and rules
- Girls do well in open ended tasks
- Boys sacrifice understanding for speedy results
- Girls want to understand in depth
Despite all these differences studies
have shown that there is very little difference in attainment.
- At age 11 boys do better than girls at maths although the
opposite is true in reading, writing and science
- At age 14 girls are slightly ahead of boys in mathematics
- At 16 performance is similar although girls do better in every
other subject
- At 18 boys outperform girls by numbers purely because more
continue to study maths. The individual girls who continue do
achieve better grades than boys.. 50 of girls choose not to
continue with a science or maths, as opposed to30% boys. At 18 they
revert to gender stereotyping.
What is happening
Expectation of teachers has a great
bearing on achievement and teachers must encourage students and
also challenge their own perceptions.
Grouping of students is important -
girls prefer co-operative supportive working environments whereas
boys do better in competitive pressurised environments. .Some
schools are experimenting with single sex classes for teaching
mathematics and English. Some schools seat boy / girl
pairings.
Mathematics lessons are set on ability
from an early age as a rule and almost always in secondary
schools.
Detailed analyses of data suggest
that:
- boys tend to show greater variability in attainment, getting
proportionately more very high or very low grades
- boys tend to perform better on recall and explanation tasks
while girls are better at handling information, observing,
inferring and investigating
- boys seem to perform better at multiple choice items and girls
at coursework and essays
- girls do particularly well in language and communication and
creative subjects and boys do consistently better in the
performance element of physical education.
In mathematics, science and
information and communications technology:
- boys have generally more positive, or sometimes more polarised,
attitudes to mathematics and science
- in physics and technology, boys tend to have more confidence
than girls in the use of physical concepts, as a result of which
their designs are more likely to be judged as having 'innovation
and rigour'
- in mathematics, boys have more confidence and are less
dependent on teachers' explanations and devise their own methods
and short-cuts to solutions
- more boys than girls see computing as enjoyable and necessary
to their future prospects; in computing, girls often have lower
expectations and less motivation.
What are we going to do now?
At school level
Schools could usefully develop a
policy on addressing gender issues supported by a school 'gender
database' comprising the school information as outlined in section
2. Below is a list of suggested approaches to investigating and
dealing with gender issues.
All teachers
- Investigate how they respond to boys and girls in their
teaching; this can involve peer observation or the use of
video.
- Investigate who and what is praised; pupils like to feel they
can do well and that their teacher cares.
- Encourage all pupils to take a more active part in
lessons.
- Encourage all pupils to take more responsibility for their own
learning and celebrate successes.
- Exploit pupils' competitiveness constructively as part of
teaching and learning (to provide contexts, analogies to help
effort, types of activity) and/or as part of a system of rewards
and incentives to complete work well.
- Involve pupils in observation and discussion of their own
behaviour to alert them to gender-related issues.
Subject departments
- Provide early and frequent feedback to pupils on their
attainment.
- Consider the composition of groups; how often do boys and girls
work in mixed pairs or groups? Are seating arrangements conducive
to learning?
- Review teachers' expectations of pupils' organisation and
presentation of notes, jotters, folders and of the prompt
submission of homework.
- Review the extent to which assessment and feedback to pupils
encourage them to identify and set themselves realistic personal
targets for improvement.
- Consider the extent to which the strengths of under-achieving
pupils are recognised and built upon.
- Build on some pupils' preference for using computers for
organising and presenting work; provide supervised access to
computers for study purposes at particular times within and outwith
the school day.
- Ensure that pupils' experiences early in S1 and S2 do not
demotivate either boys or girls in particular subjects.
Support for Pupils
- Establish a peer 'study buddy' system, using more senior pupils
as partners/role models.
- Work with pupils to set and review short-term personal targets
regularly.
- Ensure equity by gender in rewards and sanctions.
- Ensure that careers guidance and work experience is offered
equitably to all pupils regardless of gender.
- Discuss and address stereotypes and myths with pupils at an
early stage, especially by the end of S2.
- Review the gender balance and roles of visiting speakers who
have contact with pupils about their future plans.
- Identify and target under-achievers.
Actions for all: school ethos and partnership with parents
- Build a culture of achievement: celebrate success.
- Ensure that the School Board/Parent Teacher Association has the
opportunity to discuss any initiative to address under-achievement
of boys and/or girls and how the school plans to go about it.
- Provide information to employers who have links with the school
about approaches to gender issues and encourage them to support a
culture of achievement in any contacts with pupils.
- Ensure agenda for action for individual pupils are shared with
parents/carers in a positive and constructive way and at an early
stage, so that they feel that their child can succeed.
previous |
start |
next